Should You Buy a Home Warranty?

Samuel Collins • April 17, 2019

Do you need a little extra insurance on the systems in your home?

"I'm buying a house. Should I buy a home warranty?" Seems like a relatively tame question, right? But post it on Facebook or Nextdoor and watch the impassioned responses roll in. You might as well ask, "What political party should I belong to?"

Everyone has their own experience, so expect to hear a few people call them "a scam" or at the very least a waste of money. Others will regale you with their tale of how having a warranty saved them from a freezing winter because they couldn't afford to fix their furnace without it.

In the end, the decision is personal and largely based on how comfortable you are paying out of pocket if one of the more expensive items in your home, like the furnace or hot water heater, needs to be replaced. Here are some things to consider when making your decision.

Know the cost

"A basic home warranty costs about $350 to $500 a year or more," says Money Talks News. A warranty typically covers plumbing, hot water heaters, and heating/electrical system components. More expensive, 'enhanced' plans can provide added coverage for things like your washer/dryer, air conditioning system, refrigerator, septic tank, and garage door openers.

You can typically break down the annual cost into more manageable monthly payments, but the cost of the warranty itself isn't the only thing you're responsible for paying. Most home warranties include either a service call fee or a deductible, so it's important to consider those factors in addition to the home warranty plan itself.

Consider your peace of mind

Many homeowners opt for a home warranty for major "just-in-case" scenarios. Just in case the air conditioning unit crashes and burns. Just in case the hot water heater dies. With the cost of some of these items running into the thousands—the average cost for a new air conditioning unit and installation, per HomeAdvisor , is $5,413!—the peace of mind factor is huge.

"For a homeowner who doesn't have an emergency fund, or who wants to protect their emergency fund, a home warranty can act as a buffer," says Investopedia. Home warranties also make sense for people who aren't handy or don't want to deal with finding a contractor.

Understand that not everything is covered

There's always a chance that the item you need repaired is not covered under your warranty for one reason or another. Some problems simply won't be covered by a warranty, and most home warranties won't cover components that haven't been properly maintained." The lesson here: Read the fine print, so you're prepared.


Do you need some advice as you prepare your home to sell or as you begin your home search?

Contact Pro Realty Group !

Schedule a time to see this home today!

Stay in touch

  • SOLD

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • SOLD

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • SOLD

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • SOLD

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
By Samuel Collins February 22, 2026
32 Crockett Ridge Rd Black Mountain NC House Home for Sale in the Settings of Black Mountain. Panoramic Views at over 3k feet elevation. Pro Realty Group
By Samuel Collins January 30, 2026
Welcome to 301 Bexley Dr located in the privacy of Breckenridge. Cozy up next to the fireplace in the living room with tons of natural light pouring in!
By Samuel Collins December 13, 2025
Looking for privacy, seclusion, peace, & quiet? This fantastic home offers 5.2+/- private acres amongst a secluded neighborhood. Beautiful and low maintenance landscaping, impressive garden, three car garage, & large patio. Don't miss the spacious covered back deck off the kitchen perfect for bird watching, wildlife, or taking in the serene wooded area. This homes layout is very flexible and spacious over 4,000 sq ft. +/-. Grand 18 ft ceilings in the formal living room, a generous master suite w/ private balcony and updated tiled shower. The finished basement offers a work from home space, full bath, bonus room/play room that transitions to the lower level garage & oversized, well kept workshop. Extra parking pad that's perfect for parking a large RV, trucks, or farming equipment. While very private, only 30 minutes from High Point, Greensboro, & Winston Salem. In addition to Pilot Mountain State Park, Hanging Rock State Park, & Belews Lake. Photos coming soon!
2589 Leighswood Dr Winston Salem NC 27106 Home For Sale
By Samuel Collins October 24, 2025
2589 Leighswood Dr Winston Salem NC 27106 is a home for sale in the Cheslyn Neighborhood. With four bedrooms, two-and-a-half baths, pool, loft and an office!
Darwick Rd Winston Salem
By Samuel Collins September 8, 2025
1910 Darwick Rd home offers space for flexibility in room sizes and layout hardwood floors in the main primary suite is on the main level with private access to deck
1349 Brookwood Dr
By Samuel Collins September 8, 2025
Adorable First Time Home Buyer Opportunity or Income Producing Rental/Investment Property just minutes away from Wake Forest University!
By Samuel Collins June 30, 2025
97 Shadylawn Dr Winston Salem NC 27104 is for sale four bedroom three and a half bath with finished basement with sunroom and two car garage
4625 Shelton Ridge Rd Walkertown NC 27051 if a three bedroom two bath brick rancher listed for sale
By Samuel Collins May 23, 2025
Come visit this charming brick rancher tucked away with an inviting Bridge through the Laurels to the Upper Meadow on the backside of the Acreage. In this Private Oasis you will be greeted by Nature-filled days and Star-filled nights. Enjoy Birds, Wildlife and Creekside sounds from the Back Deck, Porch, or additional Deck across the Walking Bridge. Inside, you will find a Move-In Ready home with a Main-level Primary Suite. Recent flooring in kitchen living spaces and primary bedroom. Close to amenities and 15 minutes to downtown Winston Salem. Metal Roof, septic, basement Woodstove, and Sunny 1.5+/- Acreage is ready for a Garden that would be easy to take Off-Grid. The Unfinished Basement holds plenty of potential with nice ceiling height and a Locking Storage Room. Recent septic and home inspection (11/24). Our sellers life change could be the opportunity you're looking for! (Tax value from 2025 assessment value, rate and amount from 2024 and subject to change.)
By Samuel Collins December 12, 2024
Stunning Like New Home For Sale in The Landing at Rocklyn Neighborhood Located in Clemmons, NC - zoned Forsyth! Built in 2021 this Gorgeous Home has been Meticulously Maintained w/ Many Additions & Unique Features! Open Concept Kitchen w/ Stainless Steel Appliances & Updated Hardware, Cozy Living Room w/ Gas Fireplace, & Dining Room Perfect for Entertaining. Main Level Laundry Room w/ Storage. Flex Bonus Room Upstairs & Private 3rd Bedroom/Guest Suite Option w/ Additional Heating & Cooling Mini Split Addition for Maximum Comfort. Fresh Agreeable Grey Paint Throughout w/ Updated Light Fixtures. Covered Front Porch, Covered Back Patio (18x8), & Amazing Private Back Deck(16x31) w/ Stunning Nature Views. Walk In Finished Storage Room/Attic Not Included in Finished SqFt. Fridge/Washer/Dryer & All TV's Including Samsung Frame TV's to Remain in Addition to other Items. Monthly HOA Dues $160 (Landscaping) & $550 Annual (Amenities). Agents: Please See Features & Personal Property to Convey List
By Samuel Collins December 5, 2024
Super Cute & Contemporary Home For Sale in Winston - Salem, NC! Spacious & Open Concept Living, Dining, & Kitchen w/ Ample Storage Throughout. Primary Located on the Main Level w/ Walk in Closet & Full Bath. Two Bedrooms & Full Bath Located Upstairs w/ Split Layout. 1 Car Garage Perfect for Storage or Parking. Amazing Back Yard w/ Plenty of Room for Play & Activities! Quiet Neighborhood & Super Convenient to Highway access & shopping. Showings Start Friday 12/6/24 schedule your future visit Today!